Across The Aisle: Opposition in Canadian Politics by David E. Smith

By David E. Smith

How do events with respectable competition prestige impact Canadian politics? around the Aisle is an leading edge exam of the speculation and perform of competition in Canada, either in Parliament and in provincial legislatures. Extending from the pre-Confederation period to the current day, it specializes in no matter if Canada has built a coherent culture of parliamentary opposition.

David E. Smith argues that Canada has actually didn't enhance one of these culture. He investigates numerous attainable purposes for this failure, together with the lengthy dominance of the Liberal social gathering, which arrested the culture of viewing the competition instead govt; sessions of minority govt precipitated through the proliferation of events; the position of the scoop media, that have mostly displaced Parliament as a discussion board for statement on govt coverage; and, eventually, the expanding acclaim for demands direct motion in politics.

Readers of around the Aisle will achieve a renewed realizing of professional competition that is going past Stornoway and shadow cupboards, illuminating either the old evolution and up to date advancements of competition politics in Canada.

Show description

Read or Download Across The Aisle: Opposition in Canadian Politics PDF

Similar canada books

Alberta Oil and the Decline of Democracy in Canada

Ahead of could 2015, the oil-rich jurisdiction of Alberta had, for over 4 a long time, been a one-party country. in the course of that point, the guideline of the innovative Conservatives primarily went unchallenged, with reviews of presidency coverage falling on deaf ears and Alberta score at the back of different provinces in voter turnout.

Civilizing the West: The Galts and the development of western Canada

Alexander Tilloch Galt and his son, Elliott Torrance Galt, have been crucial Canadian marketers who tirelessly promoted the assets of western Canada. through the latter 1/2 the 19th and the early a part of the 20 th centuries, they labored zealously to carry the symbols of civilization to the undeveloped prairies.

Canada and the British World: Culture, Migration, and Identity

Within the aftermath of the second one global warfare, Canadian nationwide identification underwent a change. while Canadians as soon as considered themselves as British electorate, a brand new, self sustaining experience of self emerged after the warfare. guaranteed in their distinct position on this planet, Canadians started to examine the legacies and classes in their British colonial previous.

The New Hamburg Pottery: New Hamburg, Ontario 1854-1916

The recent Hamburg Pottery was once one of many twelve potteries in Waterloo County, Ontario, over the past 1/2 the 19th century. The works was once a family-operated company in the course of so much of its heritage. It used to be owned by means of individuals of the Boehler relatives until eventually 1894 then persisted less than a succession of homeowners till 1916.

Extra resources for Across The Aisle: Opposition in Canadian Politics

Example text

This was not the first occasion when the Protestant– Roman Catholic, French–English, and Quebec–Canada cleavage of Canada’s Union revealed itself – a decade before there had been the execution of Louis Riel; nor would it be the last – yet to be experienced was the tension of official bilingualism; but this time there was a new factor: a leader with the capacity and insight to interpret the controversy as an issue of federalism, to be precise, as an issue of provincial rights. Laurier did not introduce provincial rights as a cause in Canadian politics – that distinction is customarily awarded to Oliver Mowat, premier of Ontario (1872–96) – but he divined its usefulness to the leader of a federal party.

A preoccupation of colonial legislatures before the grant of responsible government was to exclude officers of government, as well as members of the judiciary: In Upper Canada … judges could [until 1838] run for election to the Lower House … In Lower Canada, however, judges were not welcome … When 26 Across the Aisle a judge was a candidate, [a legislative committee] reported: (i) the liberty of the electors was constrained, (ii) the dignity of a judge is exposed, and (iii) the confidence of the administration of justice is diminished when a judge presents himself.

By contrast, between Confederation and 1891, the year Macdonald died, there were in the United Kingdom five Conservative administrations (two led by Disraeli, two by Salisbury, one by Derby) and three Liberal (all led by Gladstone). The key reason for the difference lay in the territorial expansion of Canada, from four provinces at the outset to seven by 1873. Macdonald, besides being a master tactician in the House, was unsparing in his labours as party chieftain outside. He understood that control of the chamber depended on control of party organization in the constituencies; and Conservatives who made it to Parliament as MPs knew how they got there and where their loyalty should lie.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.46 of 5 – based on 18 votes