Download E-books Equal Recognition: The Moral Foundations of Minority Rights PDF

By Alan Patten

Conflicting claims approximately tradition are a well-known chorus of political lifestyles within the modern global. On one part, majorities search to type the kingdom of their personal photo, whereas at the different, cultural minorities press for larger popularity and lodging. Theories of liberal democracy are at odds in regards to the benefits of those competing claims. Multicultural liberals carry that individual minority rights are a demand of justice conceived of in a widely liberal model. Critics, in flip, have puzzled the motivations, coherence, and normative validity of such defenses of multiculturalism. In Equal Recognition, Alan Patten reasserts the case in desire of liberal multiculturalism through constructing a brand new moral security of minority rights.

Patten seeks to restate the case for liberal multiculturalism in a sort that's aware of the most important issues of critics. He describes a brand new, nonessentialist account of tradition, and he rehabilitates and reconceptualizes the assumption of liberal neutrality and makes use of this concept to advance a particular normative argument for minority rights. The publication elaborates and applies its center theoretical framework by way of exploring numerous very important contexts during which minority rights were thought of, together with debates approximately language rights, secession, and immigrant integration.

Demonstrating that conventional, nonmulticultural types of liberalism are unsatisfactory, Equal Recognition will interact readers drawn to connections between liberal democracy, nationalism, and present multicultural issues.

Show description

Read or Download Equal Recognition: The Moral Foundations of Minority Rights PDF

Best Political Philosophy books

The Portable John Adams (Penguin Classics)

As well as being an uncompromising defender of liberty, esteemed diplomat, and successor to George Washington, John Adams used to be a passionate and prolific author. Adams biographer John Patrick Diggins gathers a powerful number of his works during this compact, unique quantity, together with components of his diary and autobiography, and decisions from his wealthy correspondence with this spouse, Abigail, Thomas Jefferson, and others.

Between Past and Future (Penguin Classics)

Arendt describes the lack of which means of the normal key terms of politics: justice, cause, accountability, advantage, glory. via a chain of 8 workouts, she indicates how we will be able to redistill once again the very important essence of those innovations. For greater than seventy years, Penguin has been the prime writer of vintage literature within the English-speaking international.

Other Minds: Critical Essays 1969-1994

During the last twenty-five years, Thomas Nagel has performed an important position within the philosophico-biological debate on subjectivity and cognizance. This broad number of released essays and experiences deals Nagel's opinionated perspectives at the philosophy of brain, epistemology, and political philosophy, in addition to on fellow philosophers like Freud, Wittgenstein, Rawls, Dennet, Chomsky, Searle, Nozick, Dworkin, and MacIntyre.

Civic Virtues: Rights, Citizenship, and Republican Liberalism (Oxford Political Theory)

"The ebook is fantastically written, elegantly organised and it achieves with wonderful potency the entire ambitions that it units for itself. i like to recommend it warmly. "--Mind "Dagger's ebook makes a vital contribution to our figuring out of citizenship via its transparent demonstration that country advertising of civic advantage is appropriate with person autonomy.

Additional info for Equal Recognition: The Moral Foundations of Minority Rights

Show sample text content

Although, the convenience criterion can't clarify why there's unfairness right here, considering, in a Rawlsian view at the least, it applies basically to costs on discretionary items. Rawls himself has fairly little to claim approximately simply taxation in help of crucial or nondiscretionary public items. He registers a delicate choice for a proportional expenditure (or intake) tax over a conventional source of revenue tax, either one of which might arguably be in line with neutrality of therapy, due to the fact that they don't unmarried out specific conceptions of the nice for destructive remedy. yet he doesn't examine taxes on specific items or actions (such as lacrosse) or clarify even if or why he thinks they're unjust. Assuming that we do imagine the lacrosse tax is unjust, we'd like a substitute for the ease criterion to provide an explanation for why this can be so. back i believe it'd be a mistake to diagnose the prejudice by way of a contravention of the guideline of legislation. The unusual tax agenda that incorporates the lacrosse tax doesn't practice diversified tax charges to diverse individuals yet to various actions. due to the fact that any given lacrosse fan or participant can stay away from the tax by way of easily identifying a special pursuit, the folks who do decide on lacrosse are usually not being singled out as individuals for differential therapy. a greater rationalization of the prejudice produced by means of the tax is that the tax at once conflicts with the curiosity that people have in self-­determination. The lacrosse tax is arbitrary, during this account, simply because, through attaching exact burdens to people who are looking to get pleasure from lacrosse, it denies lacrosse fanatics a good chance for self-­determination. to make certain, because there is not any violation of the ease criterion within the current case, a few additional paintings is required to teach that the boundaries at the self-­determination of lacrosse fans do, in truth, deny them a good chance to gain their personal tastes. If the boundaries have been one way or the other necessary to the institution of historical past stipulations of justice, then they won't be unfair in any respect. Any form of tax diminishes a person’s self-­determination to a point, via lowering the assets they've got at their disposal to boost their ends, yet no longer all taxes are an affront to the reasonable chance for self-­ decision. the foremost characteristic of the lacrosse tax, in spite of the fact that, is that it singles out a selected job (valued by means of a few conceptions of the nice and never others) that stands in no crucial relation to justice and imposes the load simply on these those who pursue that task. 34 against this, other forms of tax, reminiscent of an expenditure or an source of revenue tax, are evenhanded within the manner they lessen the assets that folks need to pursue a few of the conceptions of the nice they carry and therefore don't unfairly reduce anybody’s chance for self-­determination. 34  At most sensible, it stands in a contingent relation to the advertising of these stipulations, for instance, simply because lacrosse fanatics are a simple goal for the tax collector, and/or simply because they have a tendency to return from prosperous backgrounds.

Rated 4.31 of 5 – based on 33 votes